Ingenious Innovations for Scanning

Everyone has heard the saying “work smarter, not harder.” The need to do more with less has only become more prominent in recent years, with project teams finding it increasingly necessary to stretch budgets and deliver quickly.

Laser scanning is a primary solution for budget optimization. Even in projects where the financials are less critical, laser scanning emerges as a desirable solution that makes planning and pre-construction easier and faster.

As laser scanning technology becomes mainstreamed today, companies are exploring future opportunities for automation and miniaturization of devices that could be worn by plant workers.

With laser scanning technology in place, algorithms comparing point cloud data and documenting changes could be delivered to procurement in as-built form. With such innovations afoot, industry professionals are analyzing how work is performed today as they plan for a future that incorporates the full benefit of laser scanning potential.

Here are insights for success.

An Integral Tool

The incorporation of laser scanning into construction projects is vital, and can even be considered urgent in today’s marketplace.

Project teams have a very small margin of error to achieve defined objectives and there are significant financial repercussions for both the project and stakeholders when goals are not met. Decision makers are looking for any opportunity to cut costs and crunching the project schedule is a key way to accomplish that aim. Reducing the project timeline – in some cases, even by one day – can result in significant savings.

Data management is pivotal to this movement to streamline project execution. The ability to collect and quantify data and recall pertinent information quickly affects all facets of the project.  Safety management, for example, becomes much more efficient when the crew can acquire data in two to three days, rather than sending a team of six to seven people into the field for two weeks to conduct an assessment.

Availability of equipment-related data is another benefit. Teams can scan a piece of equipment and reverse-engineer it, comparing the new with the old to understand the variations before the machine is even turned on, making it easier to conduct process-related planning early in the project.

Another major source of cost and schedule savings occurs when companies can handle tasks internally rather than outsourcing them. For example, 3D printing allows mass production of rendered designs whenever necessary without involving an outside party. This technology also enhances self-sufficiency, allowing companies to manufacture the tools needed to make repairs based on the material type.

This is especially useful in more remote areas or specialized industries where parts can have long lead times. This solution is even used on the international space station, where total self-sufficiency for maintenance is of the utmost importance. Such advanced technological solutions are at the forefront of market trends such as industry 4.0 and are gaining ground as these concepts take hold.

Innovative Solutions

With more agile solutions that are customized to each company’s individual needs, the number of different uses for the augmented data has substantially increased.

In one example, a facility had a 50-year-old piece of equipment that needed to be shipped to a new facility. Because stakeholders had no drawings for the equipment, the project team decided to scan it before shipment to save time in the field trying to redraw it. This also helped coordinate how to move the piece of equipment in the new facility, break apart the equipment for shipping, and document how it would be re-assembled in the new facility.  Another information-based example demonstrated how laser scanning was used in a forensic way to determine that structural damage to a column had happened several years prior.

Another project team came up with the practical application of using laser scanning to examine crane rail in a steel mill. This was more efficient than having a surveyor take shots every 25 feet over a quarter mile. What might have taken nearly a week in the past was completed in a single day via laser scanning. This was especially important because the process required a work stoppage and the laser scanning solution helped avoid several days of downtime.

In addition to saving time and money, laser scanning can improve project team relations through effective communication. 

Consider another example.  An office renovation project in an industrial building sought to relocate workspaces. The drawings available for the renovation were out of date and inaccurate. There were utilities, ramps, and elevation changes that, because of a manhole in the building with unknown connections, were unaccounted for. The team documented these variations to illuminate the costs of various solutions and inform decision making. The data from the scans proved invaluable in critical communication with decision-makers on the project.

In another case, a steel mill was designing a chute to move material into the ladle for the steel. There were issues with the placement of the chute when the furnace tilted or rocked out of position. The team scanned it in multiple positions and saw clearance issues with the chute and its location in a tight, complex area.

With scanning technology, they discovered that their original proposal would not have worked in the space and were able to use the design model to explain the problem and solution to the client in detail. This due diligence saved owners from investing in an $80,000 solution that would have been ineffective. Not only did this effort build trust between the design team and the owner, but it also resulted in a better design for the client thanks to the accurate information provided by the model.

The following images demonstrate the integration of an SSOE self-performed site scan (reality capture) into the concept development effort of an Alloy Charging System for an existing steel melt shop arc furnace. This effort required a 3D design of a charging chute that would optimize the charging slope throughout the furnace’s tapping process. The chute’s mounting system required a robust design that would align with the tight clearances associated with the existing furnace structure and allow for the accommodation of the thermal expansion associated with the furnace function. At the same time, the design had to be installable in a very tight outage window with minimal impact to the furnace proper. Many of the clearances were less than 2 inches. The reality capture and 3D model integration proved to be the ideal solution. The installation went exactly as planned and the client has continued to embrace the value of the effort as part of their ongoing operations and future capacity increase plans.